• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Brooklyn and The Butcher

Heralded as a top destination for cocktail bars, steakhouses, and seafood, Brooklyn and The Butcher in New Albany, IN, offers a sophisticated dining experience. With a diverse menu featuring raw bar selections like jumbo shrimp cocktail and Ahi tuna tartare, along with mouthwatering starters like lobster bisque and steakhouse salad, guests can expect a culinary journey like no other. The restaurant also boasts a range of additional offerings, such as outdoor seating, full bar service, and even a pool table for added entertainment. Overall, Brooklyn and The Butcher exudes elegance and flavor in every dish, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts.

Brooklyn and The Butcher: Reviews & Ratings

Patrick Lewis
Patrick Lewis

Incredible experience! This building used to be an old old hotel. Well through the years it ended up ...

Tiffany Everts
Tiffany Everts

My husband and I LOVE this place. The building is an old hotel from the 1800s! If you love history, great service, good food and drinks youll love this place! ...

Jennifer Keller
Jennifer Keller

We really enjoyed our experience. The smoked carrots were amazing! Different than any other thing Ive ever eaten. Goat cheese appetizer was also delicious.

Tulsa Petry
Tulsa Petry

We had four people and a reservation. Our table ordered cocktails, a starter, entrees, AND dessert. The entire dining experience took us two hours and we wouldve kept it going if our gluttony hadnt gotten the better of us. Not a single ...

T Quamoh
T Quamoh

This spot is an unnoticed GEM where the service was impeccable, and the food was truly delightful. The generous portions were a pleasant surprise along with the bottomless mimosas. I will definitely bre going back.

James Willey
James Willey

The service was excellent our food was some of the best I have had in a long time. The decor is simple and elegant. The food speaks for itself no need to try and describe how good the sear was or the perfect amount of sauce and seasoning. Try anything on the menu you will not be disappointed.

Dawn Polen
Dawn Polen

We celebrated my retirement at Brooklyn and The Butcher, and everything was absolutely fabulous as always! Our entire meal was delicious and cooked to perfection, and the service was outstanding. As an added touch, there was a card with a ...

Clutch Rockwell
Clutch Rockwell

We were just blown away by the incredible bar staff. We drank well , ate wonderfully and laughed immensely. Such a blast this Saturday evening. Steak tar tar, old fashions to die for, smash burger off the hook. Just a perfect time. My favorite place since moving here 5 months ago.

Location

Welcome to Brooklyn and The Butcher, a sophisticated and inviting cocktail bar, steakhouse, and seafood restaurant located in New Albany, IN. This upscale establishment offers a range of amenities, including reservations, delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating. Whether you're in the mood for a classy dinner with friends or a relaxing evening with a cocktail at the full bar, Brooklyn and The Butcher has something for everyone.

One of the standout features of Brooklyn and The Butcher is their impressive raw bar, offering mouthwatering options such as Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail, Ahi Tuna Tartare, and Yellowfin Tuna Tataki. The starters menu is equally enticing, with options like Lobster Bisque, Baby Kale Salad, and the indulgent Steakhouse Salad.

For those looking to customize their meal, Brooklyn and The Butcher offers a variety of additions such as Salmon, Shrimp, Flat Iron Steak, and Chicken. The restaurant also caters to special dietary needs with Keto options and limited vegetarian choices.

With a welcoming atmosphere, attentive waiter service, and a range of amenities including TV, pool table, and Wi-Fi, Brooklyn and The Butcher is the perfect spot for a memorable dining experience. Don't miss out on their best nights on Wednesday and the opportunity to enjoy a delicious meal in a stylish setting.

Overall, Brooklyn and The Butcher is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts looking for a mix of upscale dining and casual elegance. From the raw bar to the decadent starters, every dish is crafted with care and attention to detail, making for a truly unforgettable culinary experience. So why not make a reservation and indulge in the delights of Brooklyn and The Butcher today?